CASE STUDY · 01 MAR 2026

FASHION'S COMMERCIAL AND RETAIL TEAMS WORK TO OPPOSING INCENTIVES

In most large fashion companies, the commercial team that decides what to make and the retail team that decides what to sell work to opposing incentives, and each blames the other when a product misses. Managers who understand both functions contain the conflict. Left unmanaged, it costs margin through markdowns, missed reorders and the loss of bridging talent.

Most fashion companies above a certain size carry a conflict that comes from how they organise themselves — between the people who decide what to make and the people who decide what to sell.

Call it the commercial team versus the retail team. Or headquarters versus stores. Or buyers versus floor staff. The names vary. The conflict is the same.

The Two Worlds

In a fashion company like Zara or Mango, the commercial department — the buyers, designers, and planners — works separately from the retail operation.

The commercial team works months ahead. Their decisions are made in the abstract: based on trend analysis, past season data, supplier constraints, and market positioning. They are betting on what the customer will want in a future season, based on a combination of experience and information that they have developed over years. These are talented professionals. In the best fashion organisations, they are exceptionally talented. But by the nature of their work, they are separated from the customer by time and by the mediation of data. They never see someone pick up a garment, feel uncertain, and put it back. They see sell-through rates three weeks later.

The retail team sees exactly that. Store managers and their teams interact with the customer in real time. They see which items stop people mid-stride and which ones pass unnoticed. They hear the questions — why doesn't this come in a longer length, why isn't this available in blue, what happened to the jacket from last season? They carry an operational reality in their heads that doesn't exist in any planning spreadsheet.

These two worlds should be in constant conversation. In the best fashion organisations, they are. In most fashion organisations, they are in low-level conflict.

How the Conflict Works

The mechanism is straightforward once you've seen it.

The commercial team makes bets. Some of those bets land well — the product sells at full price, replenishment gets triggered, the category performs. Some of those bets miss. The wrong trend at the wrong moment, or the right trend executed in the wrong fabrication, or an item that worked in one market and died in three others.

When a bet misses, the retail team bears the consequence directly. They have floor space dedicated to product that customers are walking past. Their sales results reflect it. Their bonuses reflect it. The pressure to explain underperformance to regional and area managers is felt in stores, not in the buying office.

So the retail team looks at the underperforming product and draws the obvious conclusion: the buyers made the wrong call. They chose the wrong item, or the wrong colour, or the wrong price point. If the commercial team had listened — really listened — to what customers were saying on the floor, this wouldn't have happened.

The commercial team draws a different conclusion. The product is right. The problem is that stores are not presenting it properly, not training their staff to sell it, not giving it the right position on the floor. If the retail team were better at execution, the results would be different.

Both diagnoses are partially true, and neither side is entirely wrong, and that is precisely what makes the conflict so persistent. It is not resolved by being reasonable because the structural incentives are pointing in different directions.

Managers who work across both functions

The reason this conflict doesn't destroy every fashion company that experiences it is that good managers absorb it.

Not through organisational redesign. Not through new processes or communication frameworks (though those help at the margins). Through individual managers who understand both worlds and hold the tension consciously. A commercial director who walks stores regularly enough to know what the retail team is experiencing, and uses that knowledge to calibrate buying decisions. A retail director who understands buying constraints deeply enough to advocate for the floor from a position of credibility, rather than just complaint.

These people are harder to find than the role descriptions suggest. The commercial side of fashion develops one kind of pattern recognition — trend velocity, margin architecture, inventory risk. The retail side develops another — customer psychology, team management under pressure, operational execution. The crossover is rare and genuinely valuable.

When I was inside Zara, the commercial teams who consistently outperformed had two qualities beyond technical skill: they understood the sell-through pressure their decisions placed on store teams, and they respected it. They did not treat the retail operation as a distribution channel for their creative decisions. They treated it as a feedback mechanism and a real constraint on their latitude.

The inverse was also true. The retail leaders who managed the tension best were the ones who understood that commercial teams are not adversaries — they are making high-stakes decisions in conditions of uncertainty that the retail team never fully sees. Understanding the other function's constraints is a commercial skill.

What Happens When Nobody Manages It

The failure mode is visible and specific.

When the commercial-retail tension runs unmanaged, several things happen in sequence. Stores start pushing back on replenishment for products they've judged as poor sellers, even when the data might suggest otherwise. Commercial teams start designing products with less input from the retail channel, because the retail channel's feedback has become adversarial rather than useful. Regional managers spend more time explaining results than improving them. The distrust becomes permanent and costs margin.

The margin loss does not appear on a single line of the P&L. It comes through markdowns on product that was right but positioned badly. Through missed reorders on items that stores underestimated. Through the attrition of the kind of mid-level talent — the managers who bridge commercial and retail — that tends to leave first when the culture becomes political.

The CEOs I have worked with who inherited this situation uniformly describe the same experience: they can see the performance problem in the numbers, but it takes months to find it in the organisation, because no one will name it directly. It lives in the gap between what both sides are telling them.

The Diagnostic

If you are running a multi-brand or multi-country fashion operation and want to know whether this conflict is costing you, the question is not "are commercial and retail getting along?" That answer is almost always yes. The question is: when a commercial bet misses badly, what happens in the six weeks after?

Does the retail team give you a specific reading of what went wrong with the customer? Or do they tell you the product was wrong? Does the commercial team investigate what happened at store level before the next buying decision? Or do they defend the original call?

The organisational post-mortem, as distinct from the financial one, shows how the two functions work together.

// QUESTIONS

Why do commercial and retail teams clash in fashion companies?

Their incentives point in different directions. When a commercial bet misses, the retail team bears the consequence in sales and bonuses and blames the buyers, while the commercial team blames store presentation and execution.

How does the conflict between commercial and retail teams cost fashion companies margin?

The loss does not sit on a single P&L line. It comes through markdowns on product that was right but positioned badly, missed reorders on items stores underestimated, and the departure of managers who bridge both functions.

How can a fashion CEO tell whether the commercial-retail conflict is costing money?

Look at the six weeks after a commercial bet misses badly: whether retail gives a specific reading of what went wrong with the customer, and whether commercial investigates store-level results before the next buying decision.

← Back to Publications